Dean MacCannell nicely captured an aspect of this problem in his concept ” staged authenticity.” This term refers to the staging of local culture to create an. Loading data.. Open Bottom Panel. Go to previous Content Download this Content Share this Content Add This Content to Favorites Go to next Content. ← →. This chapter reviews the staged authenticity in cultural arrangements beyond tourism and the implications of this relocation, also exploring Dean MacCannell.
|Published (Last):||4 February 2011|
|PDF File Size:||20.94 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||8.81 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
The tourism industry is often accused of objectifying people and cultures in order to represent the world in the most marketable way [ 7 ]. Despite the threat posed by capitalism and globalization to cultural authenticity, there are still certain aspects of indigenous culture which is never shared. All the indigenous tourism operators interviewed for this study claimed not to have experienced any negative repercussions from tourism and to have actually benefited from the influx of visitors.
Tribal acceptance has been cited as one of the critical factors for sustainable and successful cultural tourism [ 10 ]. These scripts must be approved by a group of elders. All responses were entered into an Excel spreadsheet for ease of analysis. That said, the overall success of the indigenous tourism subsector will be achieved if financial gains do not come at the expense of the culture from which the venture draws.
Consequently, an increasing number of indigenous communities all over the world are becoming important members of the tourist industry [ 3 ]. A common theme throughout all of the interviews with the tourism operators was the necessity to tailor the experience to the audience. Some of the operators explained that they do not share cultural information pertaining to the use of medicinal plants in their territories as doing so would compromise their cultural intellectual property rights.
This however, leads to the question of who should hold the power to decide what is traditional, and therefore authentic cultural performance. This approval process gives the community a voice in the tourist venture so they can ensure their culture is being presented sensitively.
Real (or) Staged? Authenticity and Cultural Portrayal in Indigenous Tourism
The operators have a cultural obligation to protect certain segments of their culture from public display to ensure cultural sensitivity in their presentation. Indeed, in some cases, indigenous tourism presentations and performances have been blamed for upsetting the natural equilibrium destination cultures, exaggerating certain elements autheenticity ordinary life and silencing others [ 2930 ].
In this study, the indigenous operators stressed the importance of protecting sites that would be inappropriate to share with outsiders or with specific gender.
Print Save Cite Email Share. An employee explained that performers enter into an agreement with the parent corporation to be for regular wage increment. It could therefore be said that, the tourists were looking for provenance autenticity the artefacts, to judge their authenticity. If done properly, these celebrations of culture can have extremely positive impacts. The Ethics of Sightseeing. Tourists consider personal interaction with Aboriginal people a critical component of an authentic indigenous tourism experience.
Lastly, contrary to the many potential negative cultural impacts of tourism cited in current literature, tour operators are positive about the effect tourism has had on their culture so far. Cultures can also become crushed by the sheer number of tourists that flock to popular destinations [ 39 ].
Surveys were administered over a two week period to indigenous tour akthenticity and visitors at six locations throughout the region. A cross sectional survey involving indigenous tourism operators and visitors in far north Queensland was conducted, in order to gain a perspective on indigenous cultural tourism authentocity the region.
This authenticity polysemy can be advantageous in inviting the understanding of authentic within the cultural contexts of its production [ 1 ]. Tourists are more likely to resort to make-believe to overlook any shortcomings in order to have an authentic experience [ 18 ], which could explain why there were an overwhelming number of authentic responses in this study. Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content.
Staged Authenticity Today
Surveys madcannell administered to both visitors and Aboriginal ajthenticity operators in the selected towns. The problems previously mentioned in the preexisting literature are the result of a top down approach where outside groups attempt to transform Aboriginal experiences to meet market demand [ 2 ].
In addition, sharing their auhenticity can also have a positive impact on the indigenous tourism operators. The rest of the groups required to obtain approval for all cultural presentations from the elders. This makes it ideal for the development of indigenous tourism, which both the government and other stakeholders are encouraging [ 12 ].
In Australia, Aboriginal tourism has only recently emerged as an industry. According to articles 11, 14, 15 and 31 of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People, Indigenous people have a right to keep secret their sacred and ritual knowledge in accordance with their customary laws.
Staged Authenticity Today – California Scholarship
Principally, among these benefits, increased tourism can help indigenous groups overcome negative stereotypes held by members of society. Authenticity and Cultural Portrayal in Indigenous Tourism. The primary sentiment among those who expressed mixed feelings was that they had witnessed a staged performance based on the actual culture.
Tourism is one of the fastest growing industries in the world market today.